I'm forced to conclude that on my eyes, pencil eyeliners just don't cut it. I thought that the THREE flash performance eyeliner held up pretty well, but at the end of the day it does crease on me. The same goes for INTEGRATE Kira Wink Gel liners, and Pixi endless silky eye pens. I just got an ADDICTION pencil eyeliner so I'll give that one last try, then I give up on pencils. MUFE aqua eyes don't last on me either.
It's a pity. All those unobtainable pretty colors!
This probably means I should be using a primer, but I haven't figured out how to use those, and the KATE Super sharp liner still works for me, so I am fine with that.
K-Palette 1 Day Tattoo Real Lasting Eyeliner 24h (wp) is pretty easy to use, but after a few hours it smudges on my oily lids, so I won't be repurchasing. Interestingly, they didn't shy away from the word "tattoo," but Maybelline chose to rename their "Color Tattoo" eyeshadows for the Japanese market as "Color Ink."